Can Money Buy Titles?

The record breaking 15 year, $765 million contract with the New York Mets signed this offseason by four time all star, Juan Soto, marks the largest deal in professional sports history. This historic contract is set to have an extreme influence on MLB salaries, only further solidifying owner Steve Cohen’s reputation for using his wealth to build teams with championship potential. Cohen’s determination to turn the team into a consistent championship contender, despite cost, has raised the bar for big market teams, and Soto’s record breaking deal sets a new standard for superstar contracts. Soto’s deal highlights the use of long term contracts to spread out salary costs while securing star players for the future. Cohen’s bold strategy not only transforms the Mets, but also influences the entire league, signaling a new era of increasing salaries for baseball’s biggest stars.  

The wealth of MLB owners plays a key role in shaping their team’s competitive level and overall success. Wealthier owners can afford to spend more on player salaries, attracting top tier athletes through long and lucrative contracts. This is evident in the most recent spending spree by the New York Mets, who have signed numerous high priced players, aiming to be a top competitor for a championship. Historically, teams such as the Yankees and Dodgers, with deep pocketed owners, have been able to consistently maintain high payrolls and achieve sustained success. The financial resources available to these teams allow them to go after the biggest stars in free agency, creating powerful rosters that compete at the highest level year after year. 

Although wealth makes it easier to acquire talent, a team’s success isn’t solely dependent on spending. Teams like the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays have demonstrated in recent years that smart drafting, player development, and strategic trading can build a competitive roster even with lower payrolls. The Brewers, for instance, have a strong farm system and are known for developing homegrown players who can make an impact at the major league level. Their emphasis on scouting and talent development has helped them remain competitive in a market where they can’t match the spending power of the Yankees, Dodgers, or Mets. 

Prominent figures in MLB baseball have expressed mixed opinions on the influence of wealth on team success and the spending disparities between franchises. Many players support wealthy owners who invest in heavy payrolls, as it drives up their salary and sometimes even influences the market value of other players, while also displaying a commitment to winning, with Steve Cohen of the New York Mets often at the forefront of this. However, some players and small market owners have voiced concerns about the competitive imbalance created by such disparities, highlighting the need for things such as a salary cap or expanded revenue sharing in order to even the paying field. Analysts have also reflected on this issue, with some praising the quality brought by high spending teams, while others feel it alienates fans in smaller markets. At the same time, teams such as the Tampa Bay Rays and Milwaukee Brewers have demonstrated that success is not solely tied to spending, showing how strong player development can keep low payroll teams competitive. 

Juan Soto’s record breaking contract is likely to reshape Major League Baseball’s financial and competitive landscape for years to come. This deal establishes a new benchmark for elite players and provides leverage for agents to push for longer and more lucrative contracts for their clients. The trend of offering long term contracts in an attempt to spread out salary obligations is expected to continue, as teams aim to secure generational talent while managing annual payroll flexibility. While big market teams with deep pockets, such as the Yankees or Dodgers, will be able to afford to increase their payrolls, small market teams may start to struggle in keeping up financially, widening the gap between wealthier franchises and those with fewer resources. It is likely that big market teams such as the Mets, Yankees, and Dodgers will continue to dominate the free agency market, possibly causing revisiting revenue sharing agreements or implementing more rigid luxury tax thresholds in efforts to preserve the competitive balance across the MLB. In the long term, Sotos deal will either mark a period of mega contracts, or prompt the league to address the growing disparities in team spending power to ensure a competitive balance. 

 

Work Cited 

 

Brown, Maury. “MLB Has an Economic Disparity Problem; Here’s How to Fix It.” Forbes, Forbes Magazine, 13 Jan. 2025, www.forbes.com/sites/maurybrown/2025/01/09/mlb-has-an-economic-disparity-problem-heres-how-to-fix-it/. 

 

Mendelson, Nate. “Steve Cohen on Spending: ‘I’m Going to Do It My Way.’” Metsmerized Online, 29 May 2023, metsmerizedonline.com/steve-cohen-on-spending-im-going-to-do-it-my-way/. 

 

Passan, Jeff, and David Schoenfield. “Passan: Juan Soto’s Mets contract transforms New York — and the sport.” ESPN, https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/42774498/mlb-free-agency-2024-2025-juan-soto-signs-record-contract-new-york-mets-passan. Accessed 15 January 2025.

 

Roberts, Jackson. “Mets Predicted to Target $400 Million Superstar to Pair with Juan Soto.” Sporting News, 2 Jan. 2025, www.sportingnews.com/us/mlb/new-york-mets/news/mets-predicted-target-400-million-superstar-pair-juan-soto/247df6a2c1dc3457328f8acb. 

 

Rymer, Zachary D. “MLB Big-Market Spending Is Back and Better Than Ever as Cheap Owners Get Exposed.” Bleacher Report, 13 December 2024, https://bleacherreport.com/articles/10147013-mlb-big-market-spending-is-back-and-better-than-ever-as-cheap-owners-get-exposed. Accessed 15 January 2025.

 

“Steve Cohen’s Quote on Spending Money on Mets Recirculates After Juan Soto Signing.” Sports Illustrated, 9 December 2024, https://www.si.com/mlb/steve-cohen-mets-spending-money-juan-soto. Accessed 15 January 2025

 

The Yankees-Dodgers World Series Features the Biggest …, www.marketwatch.com/story/the-yankees-dodgers-world-series-features-the-biggest-combined-payroll-ever-316dff5c. Accessed 15 Jan. 2025.